Editor reviews are provided by professional editors who evaluate a blog based on the following criteria: Frequency of Updates, Relevance of Content, Site Design, and Writing Style.
User rating is calculated as an average of the user ratings. If this rating differs significantly from our editor's rating our editors may re-evaluate this blog.
You're right on the dot! Many are really "advanced newbies" who have just learned a thing or two about opt-in forms and RSS. That doesn't make them gurus. It takes much more. Good that you are pointing people to correct and accurate info!