Uh - first match with the editor. Good blog and wonderful and impressive images. Very good, well lit atmospheric work. One hair in the soup is preventing a 9 or even 9.5. There are a lot of broken links, leaving it to the ingenuity of the visitor to reach the adjacent Galleries. That needs a urgent fix. But the rest is impressive!

I don't know what the reviewing editor was on, when giving a 7 something rating. This blog delivers. Excellent quality imagery. Intimate and very well lit photos - professional work through and through. You'd deserve maybe even a ten rating - but I have to leave a bit of leeway for the top! ;) Great work!

A good blog with nice images. Good sense for composition ans style and I would have rated the blog even higher if it were not for the size of the images and the fact that they are pretty compressed. Changing that would probably warrant a 8.5 or 9 rating! Cheers

A nice blog, with nice photos and certainly something for Beagle lovers. Is it 8.7 great? My rating will not go that high - it will halt a 6.5. It is a good blog and interesting concept. Two things make my rating drop compared to the editor's review. One is the navigation - it really would be nice to have a flow - so you can move fort and back in the photo history without interruption. Second point is the image quality which is quite nice, but not outstanding. Good work nevertheless.

Excellent Photography. In some instances pushing it a bit hard what POV is concerned but all in all great imagery. Creative and inventive. Excellent Postprocessing - Braesikalla seems to have a knack for tonemapping that he masters well! Bravo!

Good and engaging Blog on the City Beautiful. Well written, it has a lot of info for anyone. Even for those living there! :) Great job!

Tacky fabulous indeed! A bit quirky with off the beaten path topics. Sure not the 1st choice for the avid Disney visitor - but a fun read it is anytime!

Again a sharp contrast to the editor. Shorpy is an exceptional photography blog, that aside from a lovingly present photography journey in our past, is also highly influential. References to Shorpy can be found in many top ranked blogs - may it be Wired, Boing Boing, J-Walk - Shorpy is in a class for itself. Highly recommended - you can get lost for hours. My tip - go - look - review. This Blog is at the top of the food chain - not somewhere in the middle.

I don't quite understand the editor's opinions. The world's best photographers, the likes of Scott Kelby, Joe McNally, Moose Peterson frequently refer to this blog as "THE" source for information on flash photography - and yet - the Editor places daily pics of dogs in 9 point plus section, while Strobist, who is a surefire help for any flash problem is down at 7 something. You got to be kidding. Check it out, and write a review and put the editor in charge to shame.